Internal vs External Penetration Testing | Vumetric Cybersecurity

Internal vs External Penetration Testing

Internal vs External Penetration Testing
Share on linkedin
Share on facebook
Share on twitter

Table of Contents

Cybersecurity is a critical component of any organization’s operations and often dictates a company’s reliability in today’s digital business world. Get it right and you secure exemplary industry reputation or get it wrong and ruin your public image, lose your competitive edge and incur losses. Penetration testing is among the most sought-after security controls, with some companies prioritizing external penetration testing and others preferring internal testing. While both have their own benefits, one certainly presents a better investment for companies. Let us take a look at the differences between internal and external penetration testing and where it fits into a company’s risk management strategy.

What Is Network Penetration Testing?

Penetration testing refers to a series of tests done to penetrate a company’s systems, applications and devices to identify any vulnerability that hackers could exploit to compromise or encrypt sensitive data, gain access to administrative features in critical systems, etc. Also referred to as ethical hacking, penetration testing checks for an organization’s technological weaknesses that could result in opportunistic attacks. These checks can target applications, systems software, devices, wireless systems and even employee susceptibility to attacks with the help of techniques commonly used by hackers.

Network Penetration Testing aims to identify vulnerabilities within a company’s network system and the impact that could result from the exploitation of each vulnerability. After testing is complete, the pentester then provides technical recommendations on how to fix each vulnerability, prioritized by levels of risk.

Here are some common uses cases for network pentesting:

  1. Following changes made to a company’s network infrastructure to ensure that no vulnerabilities have been introduced.
  2. After a business merger ensues or in the event of an acquisition.
  3. To meet requirements in regulatory frameworks. Penetration testing is one of the security controls mandated by various regulatory standards. For example, the PCI-DSS standard requires an annual network pentest to maintain compliance.
  4. To meet requirements from a third-party, such as an insurer or a business partner.

Your company’s network comprises of various links and potential points of entry, with employees forming the first major part. They, however, undergo screening tests to counter-check their ethical standards before working for your organization. Due to this, they represent a significantly less important risk for your company. On the other hand, the outside world is full of unknown hazards, with unvetted candidates looking to compromise any company’s systems at any time. The public internet is also being continuously scanned by bots used by hackers to identify vulnerabilities and perform common exploits on your public-facing technologies. This is where external penetration testing comes in.

External Penetration Testing

An external network penetration test seeks to identify vulnerabilities that attackers may exploit on public networks, such as the network used by your website or application. Administrative features are some of the most targeted areas, along with email platforms and file-sharing systems, often presenting critical vulnerabilities that allow attackers to escalate privilege or to gain access to sensitive data. Company networks can also be used for unauthorized purposes such as cryptocurrency mining and hosting phishing campaigns. These systems and devices are being regularly scanned by automated scripts and attackers all over the world looking for specific vulnerabilities and exploits present in the technologies used by your organizations, which increases the possibility that they are actively being exploited.

Rather than wait for such incidences to take action, companies conduct external penetration testing to uncover what attackers could achieve if they target their public networks. With the help of recognized frameworks and methodologies, pentesting specialists will leverage the latest attack techniques to simulate a real cyberattack and to exploit vulnerabilities while limiting any potential impact on the integrity of the systems and data. This type of assessment targets various components of public networks, such as:

  1. Firewalls
  2. FTP servers
  3. Network configurations
  4. Encryption protocols
  5. System vulnerabilities
  6. Network devices

With the help of an external pentest, organizations can cover their most prominent risks most likely to be exploited and result in an incident. Organizations with a limited budget for cybersecurity can count on external pentesting to secure their systems and assets from the most frequent type of cyberattack companies face daily.

Internal Penetration Testing

While internal penetration testing is performed less frequently, it is also a great asset for risk management strategies. It allows organizations to assess their internal networks and to uncover vulnerabilities that could be exploited by malicious employees or business partners. It is also used to determine the potential spread of a malware, such as ransomware, within internal systems/workstations/etc. This type of assessment can only be performed with a direct connection into the company’s internal network, which can sometimes hinder the process, a problem we aimed to solve with our internal penetration testing device. Its objective is to identify vulnerabilities or misconfigurations that could allow internal threats to compromise sensitive data and gain access to critical systems without any authorization, such as:

  1. Microsoft Exchange Servers
  2. Active Directory
  3. File servers
  4. Network segmentation

This type of test is better suited for organizations with a large amount of employees, companies that hold critically sensitive data internally or those looking to meet requirements from regulatory standards, such as SOC 2. While it is also a crucial component of risk management for organizations, it should not be prioritized over external penetration testing when resources for security testing are limited.

Differences Between External and Internal Penetration Testing

External penetration testing simulates the most common approach used to hack a company’s systems, performed remotely from the internet. The main goal in external pentesting is to identify and fix the most prominent cyber risks present in an organization which are constantly being probed by automated tools and hackers. Externally accessible vulnerabilities are the most dangerous, as the likelihood of their exploitation is significantly more important than internal vulnerabilities, requiring no access, credentials or knowledge regarding the targeted systems.

Internal penetration testing, on the other hand, simulates an internal threat and uncovers what could be access internally without any prior authorization. Here, the attacker already has some authorized access and is known by the organization. Its main goal is to determine what a malicious or disgruntled employee could achieve or what would be the impact of a malware spreading within the company’s networks.

The Takeaway

Penetration testing is a necessary tool that organizations must use to determine how their systems are vulnerable to cyberattacks. While internal penetration testing should not be neglected, internal threats are much less common which makes it less of a priority. External threats, on the other hand, are ever-evolving, common and are the most catastrophic to deal with.

 

 

A penetration test is a simulated hacking attempt that identifies opportunities for real hackers to break through your defences and perform various malicious acts. It generally leverages tools used by hackers and various professional methodologies to replicate the steps that modern hackers would take to intrude into your IT systems.


A pentest attempts to exploit your vulnerabilities to determine their potential impact, should they be used in a real hacking scenario. They provide a list of vulnerabilities with their respective level of severity, as well as technical recommendations to help your team apply corrective measures and focus on the most critical vulnerabilities.


These services allow your organization to answer the following questions, among several others:

  • Can a hacker gain access to any sensitive information?
  • Can a hacker hijack my technologies for any malicious acts?
  • Could a malware infection spread through the network?
  • Can an attacker escalate access to an administrative user?

Learn more about penetration testing →

There are many contexts in which a penetration test should be performed.

Here are some common use cases for a pentest:
  • As part of the development cycle of an application. (To test the security of a new feature/app)
  • To comply with security requirements. (3rd-parties, PCI, ISO27001, etc.)
  • To secure sensitive data from exfiltration.
  • To prevent infections by malware. (Ransomware, spyware, etc.)
  • To prevent disruptive cyberattacks. (Such as denial of service)
  • As part of a cybersecurity risk management strategy.
All businesses are advised to conduct a penetration test at least once a year, as well as after any significant upgrades or modifications to the company network. Given the rapid rate at which new exploits are discovered, we generally recommend that quarterly tests are performed.

The time required to successfully execute a penetration test depends on the scope and type of test. Most penetration tests can be performed within a couple of days, but some can span over several weeks, sometimes even months depending on the complexity of the project.

Various steps are taken over the course of the project to prevent the potential impact of our tests on the stability of your technological environment and the continuity of your business operations.

For this reason, a communication plan will be put in place at the beginning of the project to prevent and mitigate any potential impact. A representative of your organization will be identified to act as the main point of contact to ensure rapid communication in the event of a situation directly impacting the conduct of your daily operations, or if any critical vulnerabilities are identified, for which  corrective measures need to be implemented quickly.

While we use a simple 4 levels risk rating approach (Critical, High, Moderate, Low), our risk assessment is actually based on the Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) standard. Two main criteria are considered when  assessing the risk level of each vulnerability:

  • Potential impact: The potential impact of an attack based on a vulnerability, combined with its  potential effect on the availability of the system, as well as the confidentiality and integrity of  the data.
  • Exploitability: The potential exploitability of a vulnerability; a vulnerability that is easier to  exploit increases the number of potential attackers and thus the likelihood of an attack.  Different factors are considered when evaluating the exploitability potential of a vulnerability  (e.g.: access vector, authentication, operational complexity, etc.)

Need More Information Regarding Our Network Penetration Testing Services?

Recent Vumetric Blog Posts

What is Penetration Testing?

Penetration testing is an authorized simulation of a cyberattack on a company’s technologies. You may have also heard it referred to as Pentesting, Ethical Hacking, or Security Testing. The...

Internal vs External Penetration Testing

Cybersecurity is a critical component of any organization’s operations and often dictates a company’s reliability in today’s digital business world. Get it right and you secure exemplary industry reputation...

Main Security Testing Roadblocks for Startups

As a decision-maker in a SaaS startup, you might often find that your application security strategy is not getting the attention it deserves. There can be several pertinent reasons...

Assess Your Cybersecurity Risks

A specialist will reach out in order to:

Mailbox Icon
stay informed!
Subscribe to stay on top of the latest trends, threats, news and statistics in the cybersecurity industry.